Tuesday, 17 December 2013

Decision time

La traduzione in italiano arriverà presto!

Wild ponies, Dartmoor, UK, August 2009.

Being a full-time mum (albeit still doing some research, writing and publishing, all on a low flame) is quite of an easy choice if there is no real, appealing alternative. 

Before deciding to move to Warwick Uni, the deal with Barak was that we would go wherever one of the two would be accepted - and, well, being accepted as a master student (paying about 15.000 GBP for a one-year course) turned out to be unsurprisingly easier than being accepted as an early career post-doc in Middle Eastern Studies. 
When we moved to the UK, I was pregnant seven months and a half; then Rita arrived, and the first year for me was very difficult. Our experience with Rita's birth and the follow up we got were great, I couldn't have hoped for anything better. But I didn't know anyone, there was no family around, all was new and Rita was a bright, energetic, demanding, high-contact girl. I loved her, her smiles were my greatest joy, our closeness a mutual comfort, her conquests were deep satisfactions; I loved the look in Barak's eyes when he was with her. But Barak was very busy with his course and the sleep deprivation and the loneliness were heavy burdens. I got close to physical and mental exhaustion and I was desperate for a way out.

I enjoyed being a mum, but I would lie if I denied that I also missed my previous independent life. I missed the intellectual challenge of the PhD research; I missed writing, the words flowing with my thoughts as I was fighting what I considered consolidated biases. I missed the sense of enthusiasm that had always accompanied me while teaching, be it a University lecture or an Italian class for Israeli students, that feeling of "yes, this is the way to go!" when I managed to engage students and lead them through unexpected paths, to question their assumptions, to create questions, to provide challenges. I missed having a separate sphere for myself, for my passions: motherhood was too totalizing, I wasn't ready to be totalized.

Barak got an offer for the PhD. I tried to get back on track with the University of Warwick too; I got a non-stipendiary fellowship that led me to spend every second of the 3 afternoons that Rita spent in nursery in the Library, reading and writing like mad. I managed to participate to an interesting conference in Amman, a paper presented, 38 degrees of fever and sleep-deprived, the breast pump with me and my thoughts at home with Rita and dad. Another paper was accepted to another conference, but I thought it was immoral to ask me to pay 400£ to present the fruit of my work, with no funding from the University. I got so annoyed that I decided the effort was not worthy. 

We decided to go for the second baby. This time I knew what was awaiting me, I was prepared; we had also established the first, good friendships, mostly with other parents on our wavelength and some of Barak's colleagues. Mutual understanding is easier among parents: childless people often do not really understand the need of meeting at 17.30 so that dinner can be finished by 19.30.
Two early miscarriages later, Emily arrived. I was more relaxed, still sleepless but way less lonely. A universe of difference.

I still kept on with my low-flame research activity. A passion doesn't die in a day, nor in two years. Writing, analysing, criticising, was therapeutical, it kept me intellectually awake. I went to a conference on urban development in Berlin with 5-month-old Emily, a very considerate, quiet and interested (bored?) baby. But I also started researching education and the possibility of homeschooling the girls; I got more involved in the organic, back-to-earth stuff, changed our eating habits, trying to minimize our environmental and social impact as a family. I started a slow downshifting process.

A long premise. 
I am now in Italy with the girls, visiting the family. We arrived five days ago, a lot of excitement and sheer happiness. Three days ago, an email from Berlin: an interesting opening, a call for application for a post-doc position for women who are not already working in Germany, especially those coming back from career breakes. I was contacted by a professor I had met at the conference with Emily: working at the Habitat Unit, he liked my PhD, my presentation at the conference. He will endorse me if I decide to apply.

I have spent the last 3 days and nights thinking. Well, thinking is not the right word: tormenting myself sounds more right. Emily, with her cold, couldn't sleep and helped to keep me awake. 
The call for application is amazing. In Italy, if you are a woman and take a career break for your children, you are doomed, dead for the job market.
The field couldn't be closer to my interests: urban development from below. 
The invitation flattering: I got contacted for my work, for what I have done, by someone thinking I could further contribute to the field.
Five years ago, I would have applied without the blinking of a doubt. This is the opportunity of a lifetime.

But. 

It's not five years ago. My choices affect three more people, and two of those are under my direct parental responsibility. If I apply and get the post, we will have to relocate, again; Barak will have to stay and finish his PhD while I start my job in Berlin; we will need to organise childcare in a new environment, whose language none of us speaks. While I take the lead, Barak will have to find something to do in Berlin: possibilities are endless, but they wouldn't be at the top of his list if he could choose his post-doc without constraints.

Barak and I could still be flexible, we have always been. This does not worry me. I've learnt Arabic and Hebrew, I can learn German, and Barak too. Berlin seems a very cool city to live in, I've heard only good things about it. Barak has given me his full support.

Being full-time parents is exhausting: you are there 24/7 or almost. There is no excuse, no illness to take a break: the girls see me when I am happy, sad, grumpy, angry, enthusiastic, when I lose my patience. It is a huge effort, trying to be the best person I could so that they can aim at being the best people they can too. My actions and reactions are permanently under my own strict scrutiny because I know they can impact so strongly, and I never feel that I do enough, that I love enough. It is a knackering, constant negotiation, a constant challenge, a constant exchange: endless questions, loads of chattering, occasional screaming, little eyes and feet and hands that follow me even to the toilet or when I'm having a (sort of) coffee break. The time to think, reflect, write is stolen to my resting pauses during their short naps. The patience at the end of the day is at minimum.

The temptation to go for a job where I can deal with myself and some adult colleagues most of the time is appealing. Bad nights will then impact my results and maybe someone will get an annoyed reply, but they won't have negative effects on little souls who lovingly look at me. If I feel grumpy, I can hide behind a computer screen. I can have immediate, socially-acknowledged rewards if I work well. I can feel that with my research I am contributing to a fairer society by helping to improve the way cities are planned. I can fruitfully put to work the years and efforts I have spent studying.

Still, if I look into myself, behind the flattered and legitimately ambitious surface, I feel that I am first and above all a mum, and that my first obligation is towards our two little girls. It is a social obligation too: educating thinking, passionate, empathic little people is a huge contribution to society. Childcarers can be fantastic educators, I know, even more patient and better prepared than me, but I doubt they can act with the same love of a mother. And I believe love is crucial.
And let's be frank. If I look into myself, I know that, selfishly, I want to spend as much time as possible with our girls. It's tiring, but I enjoy it. I haven't heard of any parent regretting the time spent with their children, and I can't see myself regretting it either. 

Motherhood changed me in ways I can only minimally grasp, I know. All this might sounds traditionalist and anti-feminist, but I do not perceive it as such: feminism, as I see it, aims at the freedom to decide which role I want to undertake as a woman, beyond social constraints. I am privileged as I am exercising this freedom: many women before me (and elsewhere) could not and cannot decide.

It is not a definitive decision: in the future I might want to go back to the world of "official" work (yes, because I AM working also now - a lot!). Probably I won't get an equally good opportunity: I know and I accept it. I'll be creative, I've got a book I would like to write, stories to illustrate. They won't make me rich money-wise, but I know I have many ways to feel fulfilled. 
I don't want to give up on the opportunity to be with the girls now that they're so little. That, I know, I would regret forever.

2 comments:

  1. Elena you have my full support and quite frankly had I had the opportunity of such a choice I would have done like you, but at the time I was in Italy and I didn't feel my choice would have been socially acceptable and I would have lost my place in the job market. Now once again I have no choice and I work full time with increasing bitterness towards my job which keeps me away from my children and with this feeling that the clock is ticking and before I get the chance to spend more time with my kids they will be too grown up to want me around and I will have missed my chance. Enjoy your girls, cherish every moment and don't look back but to the future women you are growing.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Tanya for your words! Keep up, your 3 little ones are full of joy and life, and it's also because they have a mum and a dad full of joy and life... it's not a small thing!!! A hug!

      Delete