What a day.
This morning I found myself in the coffee room in the Department of Chemistry talking about water birth and baby poo with one of Barak's colleagues, whose baby is due just when my sister's one is (did I forget to mention it? Yes, my little big sister is going to join the mums' club!).
Then lunch time in the nursery: a chubby but very dry Santa (not even a single Ho Ho Ho, or a funny remark, in the whole hour he was there!) was distributing presents to the kids (no comment on the marketisation of a potentially poetic moment). The amount of pink-princess items (including a few 100% plastic tiaras and jewels, princess dolls and even a pair of pink plastic HEEL shoes - mind you, these are 3-year-old girls, not 30 year-old pinups!) was overwhelming. I was standing there, nervous, biting my lips and hoping Rita would be spared: what a sight of relief when she unwrapped an "Under the sea" puzzle (Nemo saved us). Still, I was almost crying from the pain of seeing so much pink-and-pretty stereotyping proposed (imposed?) to so many little girl's souls. When we were walking towards the car, Rita told me: "I like this present, BUT..." (mum panics) "...I wanted to get a knight's mantle!". "Fantastic, Rita! Tomorrow mum is going to make for you a knight's mantle, ok?" "Yay!!".
The whole experience was unsettling because the nursery is an educational institution, and this might be the sign of a not very implicit genderization of play and behavioural patterns (the boys, a friend made me notice, were given mostly Superhero and Knights items - brave, fighting and invincible?). We are struggling so much to let Rita be just herself, and we are glad many of her friends are male: she likes cycling, climbing, exploring as well as caring for Mimi her doll. And then, which kind of message the nursery present convey?
The whole experience was unsettling because the nursery is an educational institution, and this might be the sign of a not very implicit genderization of play and behavioural patterns (the boys, a friend made me notice, were given mostly Superhero and Knights items - brave, fighting and invincible?). We are struggling so much to let Rita be just herself, and we are glad many of her friends are male: she likes cycling, climbing, exploring as well as caring for Mimi her doll. And then, which kind of message the nursery present convey?
Since I was disconnected from digital life for the whole morning, the news of Nelson Mandela's death struck me through the radio in the car on the way back from nursery. I didn't want to hide my reactions. I found myself struggling to answer to Rita's questions and explain her who he was, why he was such a great man and what happened to him.
Rita asked me if she knew him: I told her that no, she couldn't know him because he lived in a very far country, called South Africa, the country where Noemi's mum comes from (Noemi is one of Rita's friends in the nursery - her parents migrated to Israel in the 90s, her mother from South Africa, her father from Bosnia).
She asked me what did he do. I didn't want to introduce the alien concept of racism to her: her friends come from many countries, speak many languages and have a rainbow of skin colors, and, so far, she likes them (or dislikes them) independently from that. The only thing I could come up with was that Mandela was a very wise and generous man, who understood that sharing is very difficult but also very important because only by sharing what we have we can be all happy [profusion of examples from Rita's toy-(un)sharing experiences]. So, some people who had a lot of things and didn't want to share them treated Mandela really badly and put him in a room on his own for a long time, but at the end he managed to convince them (kind of) and they also understood that sharing is good, but is still very difficult. [Anyone else tried to explain Mandela/social equality/civil rights to a 3-year-old kid? Suggestions and ideas warmly welcomed...]. I grabbed from the shop a copy of the Guardian with a huge black and white portrait of Mandela, hoping the image would somehow stick to Rita's memory and convey a depth I was not able to convey myself.
In the afternoon, the surreal but very warm birthday party of a 4-year-old kid where I felt very honoured to have been invited: Rita Emily and I were the only non-Russian speaking guests, so we caused everyone else to speak English - or at least to translate Russian for us.
Back home (with Barak still working), I miraculously managed to get the girls to sleep earlier than usual and finished my "Cinderella Ate My Daughter" (P. Orenstein) - a book I strongly recommend to anyone having to deal directly or not with little girls/teenagers. I actually think I'm going to buy some copies to give away...
Its main message is: beware of the cult of Cinderella and sisters! It is not as innocuous as it may seem - the potential negative impact of this "pink-and-pretty" culture (born, guess what, from a marketing move!) ranges from premature sexualization, distorted perceptions of femininity and girls' identity, to an increased risk of depression and/or eating disorders. It's so unsettlingly scary, as a parent and as a woman.
Apartheid, women's troubles, the girls' room that need sandpapering and painting, the difficulty of raising thinking children, identity, social justice, race and gender discrimination, the Kids Run Free race that Rita is running tomorrow (100m of fun, hopefully). I am thinking about all of this, and feeling weird.


No comments:
Post a Comment